osmo-bsc/tests/handover/Makefile.am

120 lines
3.6 KiB
Makefile
Raw Normal View History

AM_CPPFLAGS = \
$(all_includes) \
-I$(top_srcdir)/include \
$(NULL)
AM_CFLAGS = \
-Wall \
-ggdb3 \
$(LIBOSMOCORE_CFLAGS) \
$(LIBOSMOGSM_CFLAGS) \
$(LIBOSMOCTRL_CFLAGS) \
$(LIBOSMOVTY_CFLAGS) \
$(LIBOSMOABIS_CFLAGS) \
$(LIBOSMONETIF_CFLAGS) \
introduce an osmo_fsm for gsm_subscriber_connection In the current implementation of osmo-bsc, the subscriber connection is not handled (very) statefully. However, there is some state keeping in the code that handles the mgcp connection, but there are still to much loose ends which allow odd situations to happen, which then lead severe error situations (see also closes tags at the end) This commit adds a number of improvements to fix those problems. - Use an osmo-fsm to control the gsm_subscriber_connection state and make sure that certain operations can only take place at certain states (e.g let connection oriented SCCP traffic only pass when an SCCP connection actually exists. Remove the old osmo_bsc_mgcp.c code. Use the recently developed MGCP client FSM to handle the MGCP connections. Also make sure that stuff that already works does not break. This in particular refers to the internal handover capability and the respective unit-tests. See also OS#2823, OS#2768 and OS#2898 - Fix logic to permit assignment to a signalling channel. (OS#2762) - Introduce T993210 to release lchan + subscr_conn if MSC fails to respond The GSM specs don't have an explicit timer for this, so let's introdcue a custom timer (hence starting with 99). This timeout catches the following situation: * we send a SCCP CR with COMPL_L3_INFO from the MS to the MSC, * the MSC doesn't respond (e.g. SCCP routing failure, program down, ...) The MS is supposed to timeout with T3210, 3220 or 3230. But the BSC shouldn't trust the MS but have some timer on its own. SCCP would have a timer T(conn est), but that one is specified to be 1-2min and hence rather long. See also: OS#2775 - Terminate bsc_subscr_conn_fsm on SCCP N-DISC.ind from MSC If the MSC is disconnecting the SCCP channel, we must terminate the FSM which in turn will release all lchan's and other state. This makes TC_chan_rel_hard_rlsd pass, see also OS#2731 As a side-effect, this fixes TC_chan_act_ack_est_ind_refused(), where the MSC is answering with CREF to our CR/COMPL_L3. - Release subscriber connection on RLL RELEASE IND of SAPI0 on main DCCH The subscriber connection isn't really useful for anything after the SAPI0 main signalling link has been released. We could try to re-establish, but our best option is probably simply releasing the subscriber_conn and anything related to it. This will make TC_chan_rel_rll_rel_ind pass, see also OS#2730 This commit has been tested using the BSC_Tests TTCN3 testsuit and the following tests were passed: TC_chan_act_noreply TC_chan_act_ack_noest TC_chan_act_ack_est_ind_noreply TC_chan_act_ack_est_ind_refused TC_chan_act_nack TC_chan_exhaustion TC_ctrl TC_chan_rel_conn_fail TC_chan_rel_hard_clear TC_chan_rel_hard_rlsd TC_chan_rel_a_reset TC_rll_est_ind_inact_lchan TC_rll_est_ind_inval_sapi1 TC_rll_est_ind_inval_sapi3 TC_rll_est_ind_inval_sacch TC_assignment_cic_only TC_assignment_csd TC_assignment_ctm TC_assignment_fr_a5_0 TC_assignment_fr_a5_1_codec_missing TC_assignment_fr_a5_1 TC_assignment_fr_a5_3 TC_assignment_fr_a5_4 TC_paging_imsi_nochan TC_paging_tmsi_nochan TC_paging_tmsi_any TC_paging_tmsi_sdcch TC_paging_tmsi_tch_f TC_paging_tmsi_tch_hf TC_paging_imsi_nochan_cgi TC_paging_imsi_nochan_lac_ci TC_paging_imsi_nochan_ci TC_paging_imsi_nochan_lai TC_paging_imsi_nochan_lac TC_paging_imsi_nochan_all TC_paging_imsi_nochan_plmn_lac_rnc TC_paging_imsi_nochan_rnc TC_paging_imsi_nochan_lac_rnc TC_paging_imsi_nochan_lacs TC_paging_imsi_nochan_lacs_empty TC_paging_imsi_a_reset TC_paging_counter TC_rsl_drop_counter TC_classmark TC_unsol_ass_fail TC_unsol_ass_compl TC_unsol_ho_fail TC_err_82_short_msg TC_ho_int Authors: Harald Welte <laforge@gnumonks.org> Philipp Maier <pmaier@sysmocom.de> Neels Hofmeyr <neels@hofmeyr.de> Closes: OS#2730 Closes: OS#2731 Closes: OS#2762 Closes: OS#2768 Closes: OS#2775 Closes: OS#2823 Closes: OS#2898 Closes: OS#2936 Change-Id: I68286d26e2014048b054f39ef29c35fef420cc97
2018-01-28 02:04:16 +00:00
$(LIBOSMOSIGTRAN_CFLAGS) \
$(LIBOSMOMGCPCLIENT_CFLAGS) \
$(NULL)
AM_LDFLAGS = \
$(COVERAGE_LDFLAGS) \
$(NULL)
EXTRA_DIST = \
handover_test.ok \
neighbor_ident_test.ok \
neighbor_ident_test.err \
$(NULL)
noinst_PROGRAMS = \
handover_test \
neighbor_ident_test \
$(NULL)
handover_test_SOURCES = \
handover_test.c \
$(NULL)
large refactoring: use FSMs for lchans; add inter-BSC HO Add FSMs: - timeslot_fsm: handle dynamic timeslots and OML+RSL availability. - lchan_fsm: handle an individual lchan activation, RTP stream and release, signal the appropriate calling FSMs on success, failure, release. - mgw_endpoint_fsm: handle one entire endpoint with several CI. - assignment_fsm: BSSMAP Assignment Request. - handover_fsm: all of intra, inter-MO and inter-MT handover. Above FSMs absorb large parts of the gscon FSM. The gscon FSM was surpassing the maximum amount events (32), and it is more logical to treat assignment, handover and MGW procedures in separate FSMs. - Add logging macros for each FSM type: - LOG_TS() - LOG_LCHAN() - LOG_MGWEP(), LOG_CI() - LOG_ASSIGNMENT() - LOG_HO() These log with the osmo_fsm_inst where present. New style decision: logging without a final newline char is awkward, especially for gsmtap logging and when other logs interleave LOGPC() calls; we have various cases where the final \n goes missing, and also this invokes the log category checking N times instead of once. So I decided to make these macros *always* append a newline, but only if there is no final newline yet. I hope that the compiler optimizes the strlen() of the constant format strings away. Thus I can log with or without typing "\n" and always get an \n termination anyway. General: - replace osmo_timers, state enums and program-wide osmo_signal_dispatch() with dedicated FSM timeouts, states and events. - introduce a common way to handle Tnnn timers: gsm_timers.h/.c: struct T_def. These can be used (with some macro magic) to define a state's timeout once, and not make mistakes for each osmo_fsm_inst_state_chg(). Details: bsc_subscr_conn_fsm.c: - move most states of this FSM to lchan_fsm, assignment_fsm, handover_fsm and mgw_endpoint_fsm. - There is exactly one state for an ongoing Assignment, with all details handled in conn->assignment.fi. The state relies on the assignment_fsm's timeout. - There is one state for an ongoing Handover; except for an incoming Handover from a remote BSS, the gscon remains in ST_INIT until the new lchan and conn are both established. - move bssmap_add_lcls_status() to osmo_bsc_lcls.c abis_rsl.c: - move all dynamic timeslot logic away into timeslot_fsm. Only keep plain send/receive functions in abis_rsl.c - reduce some rsl functions to merely send a message, rename to "_tx_". - rsl_ipacc_mdcx(): add '_tx_' in the name; move parts that change the lchan state out into the lchan_fsm, the lchan->abis_ip.* are now set there prior to invoking this function. - move all timers and error/release handling away into various FSMs. - tweak ipa_smod_s_for_lchan() and ipa_rtp_pt_for_lchan() to not require an lchan passed, but just mode,type that they require. Rename to ipacc_speech_mode*() and ipacc_payload_type(). - add rsl_forward_layer3_info, used for inter-BSC HO MO, to just send the RR message received during BSSMAP Handover Command. - move various logging to LOG_LCHAN() in order to log with the lchan FSM instance. One drawback is that the lchan FSM is limited to one logging category, i.e. this moves some logging from DRR to DRSL. It might actually make sense to combine those categories. - lose LOGP...LOGPC logging cascades: they are bad for gsmtap logging and for performance. - handle_classmark_chg(): change logging, move cm2 len check out of the cm3 condition (I hope that's correct). - gsm48_send_ho_cmd(): split off gsm48_make_ho_cmd() which doesn't send right away, so that during inter-bsc HO we can make an RR Handover Command to send via the MSC to the remote BSS. assignment_fsm.c: - the Chan Mode Modify in case of re-using the same lchan is not implemented yet, because this was also missing in the previous implementation (OS#3357). osmo_bsc_api.c: - simplify bsc_mr_config() and move to lchan_fsm.c, the only caller; rename to lchan_mr_config(). (bsc_mr_config() used to copy the values to mr_bts_lv twice, once by member assignment and then again with a memcpy.) - During handover, we used to copy the MR config from the old lchan. Since we may handover between FR and HR, rather set the MR Config anew every time, so that FR rates are always available on FR lchans, and never on HR lchans. Depends: I03ee7ce840ecfa0b6a33358e7385528aabd4873f (libosmocore), I1f2918418c38918c5ac70acaa51a47adfca12b5e (libosmocore) Change-Id: I82e3f918295daa83274a4cf803f046979f284366
2018-05-14 16:14:15 +00:00
handover_test_LDFLAGS = \
-Wl,--wrap=abis_rsl_sendmsg \
-Wl,--wrap=osmo_mgcpc_ep_ci_request \
$(NULL)
handover_test_LDADD = \
dissolve libbsc: move all to src/osmo-bsc, link .o files Move all of libbsc/ into osmo-bsc/, and separate/move some implementations to allow linking from utils/* and ipaccess/* without pulling in unccessary dependencies. Some utilities use gsm_network and gsm_bts structs, which already include data structures for fairly advanced uses. Move initialization that only osmo-bsc needs into new bsc_network_init() and bsc_bts_alloc_register() functions, so that the leaner tools can use the old gsm_* versions without the need to link everything (e.g. handover and lchan alloc code). In some instances, there need to be stubs if to cut off linking "just before the RSL level" and prevent dependencies from creeping in. - abis_rsl_rcvmsg(): the only program currently interpreting RSL messages is osmo-bsc, the utils are merely concerned with OML, if at all. - paging_flush_bts(): ip.access nanobts models call this when the RSL link is dropped. Only osmo-bsc actually needs to do anything there. - on_gsm_ts_init(): the mechanism to trigger timeslot initialization is related to OML, while this action to take on init would pull in RSL dependencies. utils/ and ipaccess/ each have a stubs.c file to implement these stubs. Tests implement stubs inline where required. From src/utils/, src/ipaccess/ and tests/*/, link in .o files from osmo-bsc/. In order for this to work, the osmo-bsc subdir must be built before the other source trees. (An alternative would be to include the .c files as sources, but that would re-compile them in every source tree. Not a large burden really, but unless linking .o files gives problems, let's have the quicker build.) Minor obvious cleanups creep in with this patch, I will not bother to name them individually now unless code review asks me to. Rationale: 1) libbsc has been separate to use it for osmo-nitb and osmo-bsc in the old openbsc.git. This is no longer required, and spreading over libbsc and osmo-bsc is distracting. 2) Recently, ridiculous linking requirements have made adding new functions cumbersome, because libbsc has started depending on osmo-bsc/*.c implementations: on gscon FSM and bssap functions. For example, neither bs11_config nor ipaccess-config nor bts_test need handover_cfg or BSSMAP message composition. It makes no sense to link the entire osmo-bsc to it, nor do we want to keep adding stubs to each linking realm. Change-Id: I36a586726f5818121abe54d25654819fc451d3bf
2018-05-26 23:26:31 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/a_reset.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/abis_nm.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/abis_nm_vty.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/abis_om2000.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/abis_om2000_vty.o \
dissolve libbsc: move all to src/osmo-bsc, link .o files Move all of libbsc/ into osmo-bsc/, and separate/move some implementations to allow linking from utils/* and ipaccess/* without pulling in unccessary dependencies. Some utilities use gsm_network and gsm_bts structs, which already include data structures for fairly advanced uses. Move initialization that only osmo-bsc needs into new bsc_network_init() and bsc_bts_alloc_register() functions, so that the leaner tools can use the old gsm_* versions without the need to link everything (e.g. handover and lchan alloc code). In some instances, there need to be stubs if to cut off linking "just before the RSL level" and prevent dependencies from creeping in. - abis_rsl_rcvmsg(): the only program currently interpreting RSL messages is osmo-bsc, the utils are merely concerned with OML, if at all. - paging_flush_bts(): ip.access nanobts models call this when the RSL link is dropped. Only osmo-bsc actually needs to do anything there. - on_gsm_ts_init(): the mechanism to trigger timeslot initialization is related to OML, while this action to take on init would pull in RSL dependencies. utils/ and ipaccess/ each have a stubs.c file to implement these stubs. Tests implement stubs inline where required. From src/utils/, src/ipaccess/ and tests/*/, link in .o files from osmo-bsc/. In order for this to work, the osmo-bsc subdir must be built before the other source trees. (An alternative would be to include the .c files as sources, but that would re-compile them in every source tree. Not a large burden really, but unless linking .o files gives problems, let's have the quicker build.) Minor obvious cleanups creep in with this patch, I will not bother to name them individually now unless code review asks me to. Rationale: 1) libbsc has been separate to use it for osmo-nitb and osmo-bsc in the old openbsc.git. This is no longer required, and spreading over libbsc and osmo-bsc is distracting. 2) Recently, ridiculous linking requirements have made adding new functions cumbersome, because libbsc has started depending on osmo-bsc/*.c implementations: on gscon FSM and bssap functions. For example, neither bs11_config nor ipaccess-config nor bts_test need handover_cfg or BSSMAP message composition. It makes no sense to link the entire osmo-bsc to it, nor do we want to keep adding stubs to each linking realm. Change-Id: I36a586726f5818121abe54d25654819fc451d3bf
2018-05-26 23:26:31 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/abis_rsl.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/acc.o \
dissolve libbsc: move all to src/osmo-bsc, link .o files Move all of libbsc/ into osmo-bsc/, and separate/move some implementations to allow linking from utils/* and ipaccess/* without pulling in unccessary dependencies. Some utilities use gsm_network and gsm_bts structs, which already include data structures for fairly advanced uses. Move initialization that only osmo-bsc needs into new bsc_network_init() and bsc_bts_alloc_register() functions, so that the leaner tools can use the old gsm_* versions without the need to link everything (e.g. handover and lchan alloc code). In some instances, there need to be stubs if to cut off linking "just before the RSL level" and prevent dependencies from creeping in. - abis_rsl_rcvmsg(): the only program currently interpreting RSL messages is osmo-bsc, the utils are merely concerned with OML, if at all. - paging_flush_bts(): ip.access nanobts models call this when the RSL link is dropped. Only osmo-bsc actually needs to do anything there. - on_gsm_ts_init(): the mechanism to trigger timeslot initialization is related to OML, while this action to take on init would pull in RSL dependencies. utils/ and ipaccess/ each have a stubs.c file to implement these stubs. Tests implement stubs inline where required. From src/utils/, src/ipaccess/ and tests/*/, link in .o files from osmo-bsc/. In order for this to work, the osmo-bsc subdir must be built before the other source trees. (An alternative would be to include the .c files as sources, but that would re-compile them in every source tree. Not a large burden really, but unless linking .o files gives problems, let's have the quicker build.) Minor obvious cleanups creep in with this patch, I will not bother to name them individually now unless code review asks me to. Rationale: 1) libbsc has been separate to use it for osmo-nitb and osmo-bsc in the old openbsc.git. This is no longer required, and spreading over libbsc and osmo-bsc is distracting. 2) Recently, ridiculous linking requirements have made adding new functions cumbersome, because libbsc has started depending on osmo-bsc/*.c implementations: on gscon FSM and bssap functions. For example, neither bs11_config nor ipaccess-config nor bts_test need handover_cfg or BSSMAP message composition. It makes no sense to link the entire osmo-bsc to it, nor do we want to keep adding stubs to each linking realm. Change-Id: I36a586726f5818121abe54d25654819fc451d3bf
2018-05-26 23:26:31 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/arfcn_range_encode.o \
large refactoring: use FSMs for lchans; add inter-BSC HO Add FSMs: - timeslot_fsm: handle dynamic timeslots and OML+RSL availability. - lchan_fsm: handle an individual lchan activation, RTP stream and release, signal the appropriate calling FSMs on success, failure, release. - mgw_endpoint_fsm: handle one entire endpoint with several CI. - assignment_fsm: BSSMAP Assignment Request. - handover_fsm: all of intra, inter-MO and inter-MT handover. Above FSMs absorb large parts of the gscon FSM. The gscon FSM was surpassing the maximum amount events (32), and it is more logical to treat assignment, handover and MGW procedures in separate FSMs. - Add logging macros for each FSM type: - LOG_TS() - LOG_LCHAN() - LOG_MGWEP(), LOG_CI() - LOG_ASSIGNMENT() - LOG_HO() These log with the osmo_fsm_inst where present. New style decision: logging without a final newline char is awkward, especially for gsmtap logging and when other logs interleave LOGPC() calls; we have various cases where the final \n goes missing, and also this invokes the log category checking N times instead of once. So I decided to make these macros *always* append a newline, but only if there is no final newline yet. I hope that the compiler optimizes the strlen() of the constant format strings away. Thus I can log with or without typing "\n" and always get an \n termination anyway. General: - replace osmo_timers, state enums and program-wide osmo_signal_dispatch() with dedicated FSM timeouts, states and events. - introduce a common way to handle Tnnn timers: gsm_timers.h/.c: struct T_def. These can be used (with some macro magic) to define a state's timeout once, and not make mistakes for each osmo_fsm_inst_state_chg(). Details: bsc_subscr_conn_fsm.c: - move most states of this FSM to lchan_fsm, assignment_fsm, handover_fsm and mgw_endpoint_fsm. - There is exactly one state for an ongoing Assignment, with all details handled in conn->assignment.fi. The state relies on the assignment_fsm's timeout. - There is one state for an ongoing Handover; except for an incoming Handover from a remote BSS, the gscon remains in ST_INIT until the new lchan and conn are both established. - move bssmap_add_lcls_status() to osmo_bsc_lcls.c abis_rsl.c: - move all dynamic timeslot logic away into timeslot_fsm. Only keep plain send/receive functions in abis_rsl.c - reduce some rsl functions to merely send a message, rename to "_tx_". - rsl_ipacc_mdcx(): add '_tx_' in the name; move parts that change the lchan state out into the lchan_fsm, the lchan->abis_ip.* are now set there prior to invoking this function. - move all timers and error/release handling away into various FSMs. - tweak ipa_smod_s_for_lchan() and ipa_rtp_pt_for_lchan() to not require an lchan passed, but just mode,type that they require. Rename to ipacc_speech_mode*() and ipacc_payload_type(). - add rsl_forward_layer3_info, used for inter-BSC HO MO, to just send the RR message received during BSSMAP Handover Command. - move various logging to LOG_LCHAN() in order to log with the lchan FSM instance. One drawback is that the lchan FSM is limited to one logging category, i.e. this moves some logging from DRR to DRSL. It might actually make sense to combine those categories. - lose LOGP...LOGPC logging cascades: they are bad for gsmtap logging and for performance. - handle_classmark_chg(): change logging, move cm2 len check out of the cm3 condition (I hope that's correct). - gsm48_send_ho_cmd(): split off gsm48_make_ho_cmd() which doesn't send right away, so that during inter-bsc HO we can make an RR Handover Command to send via the MSC to the remote BSS. assignment_fsm.c: - the Chan Mode Modify in case of re-using the same lchan is not implemented yet, because this was also missing in the previous implementation (OS#3357). osmo_bsc_api.c: - simplify bsc_mr_config() and move to lchan_fsm.c, the only caller; rename to lchan_mr_config(). (bsc_mr_config() used to copy the values to mr_bts_lv twice, once by member assignment and then again with a memcpy.) - During handover, we used to copy the MR config from the old lchan. Since we may handover between FR and HR, rather set the MR Config anew every time, so that FR rates are always available on FR lchans, and never on HR lchans. Depends: I03ee7ce840ecfa0b6a33358e7385528aabd4873f (libosmocore), I1f2918418c38918c5ac70acaa51a47adfca12b5e (libosmocore) Change-Id: I82e3f918295daa83274a4cf803f046979f284366
2018-05-14 16:14:15 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/assignment_fsm.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/bsc_ctrl_commands.o \
dissolve libbsc: move all to src/osmo-bsc, link .o files Move all of libbsc/ into osmo-bsc/, and separate/move some implementations to allow linking from utils/* and ipaccess/* without pulling in unccessary dependencies. Some utilities use gsm_network and gsm_bts structs, which already include data structures for fairly advanced uses. Move initialization that only osmo-bsc needs into new bsc_network_init() and bsc_bts_alloc_register() functions, so that the leaner tools can use the old gsm_* versions without the need to link everything (e.g. handover and lchan alloc code). In some instances, there need to be stubs if to cut off linking "just before the RSL level" and prevent dependencies from creeping in. - abis_rsl_rcvmsg(): the only program currently interpreting RSL messages is osmo-bsc, the utils are merely concerned with OML, if at all. - paging_flush_bts(): ip.access nanobts models call this when the RSL link is dropped. Only osmo-bsc actually needs to do anything there. - on_gsm_ts_init(): the mechanism to trigger timeslot initialization is related to OML, while this action to take on init would pull in RSL dependencies. utils/ and ipaccess/ each have a stubs.c file to implement these stubs. Tests implement stubs inline where required. From src/utils/, src/ipaccess/ and tests/*/, link in .o files from osmo-bsc/. In order for this to work, the osmo-bsc subdir must be built before the other source trees. (An alternative would be to include the .c files as sources, but that would re-compile them in every source tree. Not a large burden really, but unless linking .o files gives problems, let's have the quicker build.) Minor obvious cleanups creep in with this patch, I will not bother to name them individually now unless code review asks me to. Rationale: 1) libbsc has been separate to use it for osmo-nitb and osmo-bsc in the old openbsc.git. This is no longer required, and spreading over libbsc and osmo-bsc is distracting. 2) Recently, ridiculous linking requirements have made adding new functions cumbersome, because libbsc has started depending on osmo-bsc/*.c implementations: on gscon FSM and bssap functions. For example, neither bs11_config nor ipaccess-config nor bts_test need handover_cfg or BSSMAP message composition. It makes no sense to link the entire osmo-bsc to it, nor do we want to keep adding stubs to each linking realm. Change-Id: I36a586726f5818121abe54d25654819fc451d3bf
2018-05-26 23:26:31 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/bsc_init.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/bsc_rf_ctrl.o \
dissolve libbsc: move all to src/osmo-bsc, link .o files Move all of libbsc/ into osmo-bsc/, and separate/move some implementations to allow linking from utils/* and ipaccess/* without pulling in unccessary dependencies. Some utilities use gsm_network and gsm_bts structs, which already include data structures for fairly advanced uses. Move initialization that only osmo-bsc needs into new bsc_network_init() and bsc_bts_alloc_register() functions, so that the leaner tools can use the old gsm_* versions without the need to link everything (e.g. handover and lchan alloc code). In some instances, there need to be stubs if to cut off linking "just before the RSL level" and prevent dependencies from creeping in. - abis_rsl_rcvmsg(): the only program currently interpreting RSL messages is osmo-bsc, the utils are merely concerned with OML, if at all. - paging_flush_bts(): ip.access nanobts models call this when the RSL link is dropped. Only osmo-bsc actually needs to do anything there. - on_gsm_ts_init(): the mechanism to trigger timeslot initialization is related to OML, while this action to take on init would pull in RSL dependencies. utils/ and ipaccess/ each have a stubs.c file to implement these stubs. Tests implement stubs inline where required. From src/utils/, src/ipaccess/ and tests/*/, link in .o files from osmo-bsc/. In order for this to work, the osmo-bsc subdir must be built before the other source trees. (An alternative would be to include the .c files as sources, but that would re-compile them in every source tree. Not a large burden really, but unless linking .o files gives problems, let's have the quicker build.) Minor obvious cleanups creep in with this patch, I will not bother to name them individually now unless code review asks me to. Rationale: 1) libbsc has been separate to use it for osmo-nitb and osmo-bsc in the old openbsc.git. This is no longer required, and spreading over libbsc and osmo-bsc is distracting. 2) Recently, ridiculous linking requirements have made adding new functions cumbersome, because libbsc has started depending on osmo-bsc/*.c implementations: on gscon FSM and bssap functions. For example, neither bs11_config nor ipaccess-config nor bts_test need handover_cfg or BSSMAP message composition. It makes no sense to link the entire osmo-bsc to it, nor do we want to keep adding stubs to each linking realm. Change-Id: I36a586726f5818121abe54d25654819fc451d3bf
2018-05-26 23:26:31 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/bsc_rll.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/bsc_subscr_conn_fsm.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/bsc_subscriber.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/bsc_vty.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/bts.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/bts_trx.o \
dissolve libbsc: move all to src/osmo-bsc, link .o files Move all of libbsc/ into osmo-bsc/, and separate/move some implementations to allow linking from utils/* and ipaccess/* without pulling in unccessary dependencies. Some utilities use gsm_network and gsm_bts structs, which already include data structures for fairly advanced uses. Move initialization that only osmo-bsc needs into new bsc_network_init() and bsc_bts_alloc_register() functions, so that the leaner tools can use the old gsm_* versions without the need to link everything (e.g. handover and lchan alloc code). In some instances, there need to be stubs if to cut off linking "just before the RSL level" and prevent dependencies from creeping in. - abis_rsl_rcvmsg(): the only program currently interpreting RSL messages is osmo-bsc, the utils are merely concerned with OML, if at all. - paging_flush_bts(): ip.access nanobts models call this when the RSL link is dropped. Only osmo-bsc actually needs to do anything there. - on_gsm_ts_init(): the mechanism to trigger timeslot initialization is related to OML, while this action to take on init would pull in RSL dependencies. utils/ and ipaccess/ each have a stubs.c file to implement these stubs. Tests implement stubs inline where required. From src/utils/, src/ipaccess/ and tests/*/, link in .o files from osmo-bsc/. In order for this to work, the osmo-bsc subdir must be built before the other source trees. (An alternative would be to include the .c files as sources, but that would re-compile them in every source tree. Not a large burden really, but unless linking .o files gives problems, let's have the quicker build.) Minor obvious cleanups creep in with this patch, I will not bother to name them individually now unless code review asks me to. Rationale: 1) libbsc has been separate to use it for osmo-nitb and osmo-bsc in the old openbsc.git. This is no longer required, and spreading over libbsc and osmo-bsc is distracting. 2) Recently, ridiculous linking requirements have made adding new functions cumbersome, because libbsc has started depending on osmo-bsc/*.c implementations: on gscon FSM and bssap functions. For example, neither bs11_config nor ipaccess-config nor bts_test need handover_cfg or BSSMAP message composition. It makes no sense to link the entire osmo-bsc to it, nor do we want to keep adding stubs to each linking realm. Change-Id: I36a586726f5818121abe54d25654819fc451d3bf
2018-05-26 23:26:31 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/bts_ipaccess_nanobts.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/bts_ipaccess_nanobts_omlattr.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/bts_unknown.o \
dissolve libbsc: move all to src/osmo-bsc, link .o files Move all of libbsc/ into osmo-bsc/, and separate/move some implementations to allow linking from utils/* and ipaccess/* without pulling in unccessary dependencies. Some utilities use gsm_network and gsm_bts structs, which already include data structures for fairly advanced uses. Move initialization that only osmo-bsc needs into new bsc_network_init() and bsc_bts_alloc_register() functions, so that the leaner tools can use the old gsm_* versions without the need to link everything (e.g. handover and lchan alloc code). In some instances, there need to be stubs if to cut off linking "just before the RSL level" and prevent dependencies from creeping in. - abis_rsl_rcvmsg(): the only program currently interpreting RSL messages is osmo-bsc, the utils are merely concerned with OML, if at all. - paging_flush_bts(): ip.access nanobts models call this when the RSL link is dropped. Only osmo-bsc actually needs to do anything there. - on_gsm_ts_init(): the mechanism to trigger timeslot initialization is related to OML, while this action to take on init would pull in RSL dependencies. utils/ and ipaccess/ each have a stubs.c file to implement these stubs. Tests implement stubs inline where required. From src/utils/, src/ipaccess/ and tests/*/, link in .o files from osmo-bsc/. In order for this to work, the osmo-bsc subdir must be built before the other source trees. (An alternative would be to include the .c files as sources, but that would re-compile them in every source tree. Not a large burden really, but unless linking .o files gives problems, let's have the quicker build.) Minor obvious cleanups creep in with this patch, I will not bother to name them individually now unless code review asks me to. Rationale: 1) libbsc has been separate to use it for osmo-nitb and osmo-bsc in the old openbsc.git. This is no longer required, and spreading over libbsc and osmo-bsc is distracting. 2) Recently, ridiculous linking requirements have made adding new functions cumbersome, because libbsc has started depending on osmo-bsc/*.c implementations: on gscon FSM and bssap functions. For example, neither bs11_config nor ipaccess-config nor bts_test need handover_cfg or BSSMAP message composition. It makes no sense to link the entire osmo-bsc to it, nor do we want to keep adding stubs to each linking realm. Change-Id: I36a586726f5818121abe54d25654819fc451d3bf
2018-05-26 23:26:31 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/chan_alloc.o \
large refactoring: use FSMs for lchans; add inter-BSC HO Add FSMs: - timeslot_fsm: handle dynamic timeslots and OML+RSL availability. - lchan_fsm: handle an individual lchan activation, RTP stream and release, signal the appropriate calling FSMs on success, failure, release. - mgw_endpoint_fsm: handle one entire endpoint with several CI. - assignment_fsm: BSSMAP Assignment Request. - handover_fsm: all of intra, inter-MO and inter-MT handover. Above FSMs absorb large parts of the gscon FSM. The gscon FSM was surpassing the maximum amount events (32), and it is more logical to treat assignment, handover and MGW procedures in separate FSMs. - Add logging macros for each FSM type: - LOG_TS() - LOG_LCHAN() - LOG_MGWEP(), LOG_CI() - LOG_ASSIGNMENT() - LOG_HO() These log with the osmo_fsm_inst where present. New style decision: logging without a final newline char is awkward, especially for gsmtap logging and when other logs interleave LOGPC() calls; we have various cases where the final \n goes missing, and also this invokes the log category checking N times instead of once. So I decided to make these macros *always* append a newline, but only if there is no final newline yet. I hope that the compiler optimizes the strlen() of the constant format strings away. Thus I can log with or without typing "\n" and always get an \n termination anyway. General: - replace osmo_timers, state enums and program-wide osmo_signal_dispatch() with dedicated FSM timeouts, states and events. - introduce a common way to handle Tnnn timers: gsm_timers.h/.c: struct T_def. These can be used (with some macro magic) to define a state's timeout once, and not make mistakes for each osmo_fsm_inst_state_chg(). Details: bsc_subscr_conn_fsm.c: - move most states of this FSM to lchan_fsm, assignment_fsm, handover_fsm and mgw_endpoint_fsm. - There is exactly one state for an ongoing Assignment, with all details handled in conn->assignment.fi. The state relies on the assignment_fsm's timeout. - There is one state for an ongoing Handover; except for an incoming Handover from a remote BSS, the gscon remains in ST_INIT until the new lchan and conn are both established. - move bssmap_add_lcls_status() to osmo_bsc_lcls.c abis_rsl.c: - move all dynamic timeslot logic away into timeslot_fsm. Only keep plain send/receive functions in abis_rsl.c - reduce some rsl functions to merely send a message, rename to "_tx_". - rsl_ipacc_mdcx(): add '_tx_' in the name; move parts that change the lchan state out into the lchan_fsm, the lchan->abis_ip.* are now set there prior to invoking this function. - move all timers and error/release handling away into various FSMs. - tweak ipa_smod_s_for_lchan() and ipa_rtp_pt_for_lchan() to not require an lchan passed, but just mode,type that they require. Rename to ipacc_speech_mode*() and ipacc_payload_type(). - add rsl_forward_layer3_info, used for inter-BSC HO MO, to just send the RR message received during BSSMAP Handover Command. - move various logging to LOG_LCHAN() in order to log with the lchan FSM instance. One drawback is that the lchan FSM is limited to one logging category, i.e. this moves some logging from DRR to DRSL. It might actually make sense to combine those categories. - lose LOGP...LOGPC logging cascades: they are bad for gsmtap logging and for performance. - handle_classmark_chg(): change logging, move cm2 len check out of the cm3 condition (I hope that's correct). - gsm48_send_ho_cmd(): split off gsm48_make_ho_cmd() which doesn't send right away, so that during inter-bsc HO we can make an RR Handover Command to send via the MSC to the remote BSS. assignment_fsm.c: - the Chan Mode Modify in case of re-using the same lchan is not implemented yet, because this was also missing in the previous implementation (OS#3357). osmo_bsc_api.c: - simplify bsc_mr_config() and move to lchan_fsm.c, the only caller; rename to lchan_mr_config(). (bsc_mr_config() used to copy the values to mr_bts_lv twice, once by member assignment and then again with a memcpy.) - During handover, we used to copy the MR config from the old lchan. Since we may handover between FR and HR, rather set the MR Config anew every time, so that FR rates are always available on FR lchans, and never on HR lchans. Depends: I03ee7ce840ecfa0b6a33358e7385528aabd4873f (libosmocore), I1f2918418c38918c5ac70acaa51a47adfca12b5e (libosmocore) Change-Id: I82e3f918295daa83274a4cf803f046979f284366
2018-05-14 16:14:15 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/codec_pref.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/gsm_04_08_rr.o \
dissolve libbsc: move all to src/osmo-bsc, link .o files Move all of libbsc/ into osmo-bsc/, and separate/move some implementations to allow linking from utils/* and ipaccess/* without pulling in unccessary dependencies. Some utilities use gsm_network and gsm_bts structs, which already include data structures for fairly advanced uses. Move initialization that only osmo-bsc needs into new bsc_network_init() and bsc_bts_alloc_register() functions, so that the leaner tools can use the old gsm_* versions without the need to link everything (e.g. handover and lchan alloc code). In some instances, there need to be stubs if to cut off linking "just before the RSL level" and prevent dependencies from creeping in. - abis_rsl_rcvmsg(): the only program currently interpreting RSL messages is osmo-bsc, the utils are merely concerned with OML, if at all. - paging_flush_bts(): ip.access nanobts models call this when the RSL link is dropped. Only osmo-bsc actually needs to do anything there. - on_gsm_ts_init(): the mechanism to trigger timeslot initialization is related to OML, while this action to take on init would pull in RSL dependencies. utils/ and ipaccess/ each have a stubs.c file to implement these stubs. Tests implement stubs inline where required. From src/utils/, src/ipaccess/ and tests/*/, link in .o files from osmo-bsc/. In order for this to work, the osmo-bsc subdir must be built before the other source trees. (An alternative would be to include the .c files as sources, but that would re-compile them in every source tree. Not a large burden really, but unless linking .o files gives problems, let's have the quicker build.) Minor obvious cleanups creep in with this patch, I will not bother to name them individually now unless code review asks me to. Rationale: 1) libbsc has been separate to use it for osmo-nitb and osmo-bsc in the old openbsc.git. This is no longer required, and spreading over libbsc and osmo-bsc is distracting. 2) Recently, ridiculous linking requirements have made adding new functions cumbersome, because libbsc has started depending on osmo-bsc/*.c implementations: on gscon FSM and bssap functions. For example, neither bs11_config nor ipaccess-config nor bts_test need handover_cfg or BSSMAP message composition. It makes no sense to link the entire osmo-bsc to it, nor do we want to keep adding stubs to each linking realm. Change-Id: I36a586726f5818121abe54d25654819fc451d3bf
2018-05-26 23:26:31 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/gsm_data.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/handover_cfg.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/handover_decision.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/handover_decision_2.o \
large refactoring: use FSMs for lchans; add inter-BSC HO Add FSMs: - timeslot_fsm: handle dynamic timeslots and OML+RSL availability. - lchan_fsm: handle an individual lchan activation, RTP stream and release, signal the appropriate calling FSMs on success, failure, release. - mgw_endpoint_fsm: handle one entire endpoint with several CI. - assignment_fsm: BSSMAP Assignment Request. - handover_fsm: all of intra, inter-MO and inter-MT handover. Above FSMs absorb large parts of the gscon FSM. The gscon FSM was surpassing the maximum amount events (32), and it is more logical to treat assignment, handover and MGW procedures in separate FSMs. - Add logging macros for each FSM type: - LOG_TS() - LOG_LCHAN() - LOG_MGWEP(), LOG_CI() - LOG_ASSIGNMENT() - LOG_HO() These log with the osmo_fsm_inst where present. New style decision: logging without a final newline char is awkward, especially for gsmtap logging and when other logs interleave LOGPC() calls; we have various cases where the final \n goes missing, and also this invokes the log category checking N times instead of once. So I decided to make these macros *always* append a newline, but only if there is no final newline yet. I hope that the compiler optimizes the strlen() of the constant format strings away. Thus I can log with or without typing "\n" and always get an \n termination anyway. General: - replace osmo_timers, state enums and program-wide osmo_signal_dispatch() with dedicated FSM timeouts, states and events. - introduce a common way to handle Tnnn timers: gsm_timers.h/.c: struct T_def. These can be used (with some macro magic) to define a state's timeout once, and not make mistakes for each osmo_fsm_inst_state_chg(). Details: bsc_subscr_conn_fsm.c: - move most states of this FSM to lchan_fsm, assignment_fsm, handover_fsm and mgw_endpoint_fsm. - There is exactly one state for an ongoing Assignment, with all details handled in conn->assignment.fi. The state relies on the assignment_fsm's timeout. - There is one state for an ongoing Handover; except for an incoming Handover from a remote BSS, the gscon remains in ST_INIT until the new lchan and conn are both established. - move bssmap_add_lcls_status() to osmo_bsc_lcls.c abis_rsl.c: - move all dynamic timeslot logic away into timeslot_fsm. Only keep plain send/receive functions in abis_rsl.c - reduce some rsl functions to merely send a message, rename to "_tx_". - rsl_ipacc_mdcx(): add '_tx_' in the name; move parts that change the lchan state out into the lchan_fsm, the lchan->abis_ip.* are now set there prior to invoking this function. - move all timers and error/release handling away into various FSMs. - tweak ipa_smod_s_for_lchan() and ipa_rtp_pt_for_lchan() to not require an lchan passed, but just mode,type that they require. Rename to ipacc_speech_mode*() and ipacc_payload_type(). - add rsl_forward_layer3_info, used for inter-BSC HO MO, to just send the RR message received during BSSMAP Handover Command. - move various logging to LOG_LCHAN() in order to log with the lchan FSM instance. One drawback is that the lchan FSM is limited to one logging category, i.e. this moves some logging from DRR to DRSL. It might actually make sense to combine those categories. - lose LOGP...LOGPC logging cascades: they are bad for gsmtap logging and for performance. - handle_classmark_chg(): change logging, move cm2 len check out of the cm3 condition (I hope that's correct). - gsm48_send_ho_cmd(): split off gsm48_make_ho_cmd() which doesn't send right away, so that during inter-bsc HO we can make an RR Handover Command to send via the MSC to the remote BSS. assignment_fsm.c: - the Chan Mode Modify in case of re-using the same lchan is not implemented yet, because this was also missing in the previous implementation (OS#3357). osmo_bsc_api.c: - simplify bsc_mr_config() and move to lchan_fsm.c, the only caller; rename to lchan_mr_config(). (bsc_mr_config() used to copy the values to mr_bts_lv twice, once by member assignment and then again with a memcpy.) - During handover, we used to copy the MR config from the old lchan. Since we may handover between FR and HR, rather set the MR Config anew every time, so that FR rates are always available on FR lchans, and never on HR lchans. Depends: I03ee7ce840ecfa0b6a33358e7385528aabd4873f (libosmocore), I1f2918418c38918c5ac70acaa51a47adfca12b5e (libosmocore) Change-Id: I82e3f918295daa83274a4cf803f046979f284366
2018-05-14 16:14:15 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/handover_fsm.o \
dissolve libbsc: move all to src/osmo-bsc, link .o files Move all of libbsc/ into osmo-bsc/, and separate/move some implementations to allow linking from utils/* and ipaccess/* without pulling in unccessary dependencies. Some utilities use gsm_network and gsm_bts structs, which already include data structures for fairly advanced uses. Move initialization that only osmo-bsc needs into new bsc_network_init() and bsc_bts_alloc_register() functions, so that the leaner tools can use the old gsm_* versions without the need to link everything (e.g. handover and lchan alloc code). In some instances, there need to be stubs if to cut off linking "just before the RSL level" and prevent dependencies from creeping in. - abis_rsl_rcvmsg(): the only program currently interpreting RSL messages is osmo-bsc, the utils are merely concerned with OML, if at all. - paging_flush_bts(): ip.access nanobts models call this when the RSL link is dropped. Only osmo-bsc actually needs to do anything there. - on_gsm_ts_init(): the mechanism to trigger timeslot initialization is related to OML, while this action to take on init would pull in RSL dependencies. utils/ and ipaccess/ each have a stubs.c file to implement these stubs. Tests implement stubs inline where required. From src/utils/, src/ipaccess/ and tests/*/, link in .o files from osmo-bsc/. In order for this to work, the osmo-bsc subdir must be built before the other source trees. (An alternative would be to include the .c files as sources, but that would re-compile them in every source tree. Not a large burden really, but unless linking .o files gives problems, let's have the quicker build.) Minor obvious cleanups creep in with this patch, I will not bother to name them individually now unless code review asks me to. Rationale: 1) libbsc has been separate to use it for osmo-nitb and osmo-bsc in the old openbsc.git. This is no longer required, and spreading over libbsc and osmo-bsc is distracting. 2) Recently, ridiculous linking requirements have made adding new functions cumbersome, because libbsc has started depending on osmo-bsc/*.c implementations: on gscon FSM and bssap functions. For example, neither bs11_config nor ipaccess-config nor bts_test need handover_cfg or BSSMAP message composition. It makes no sense to link the entire osmo-bsc to it, nor do we want to keep adding stubs to each linking realm. Change-Id: I36a586726f5818121abe54d25654819fc451d3bf
2018-05-26 23:26:31 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/handover_logic.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/handover_vty.o \
large refactoring: use FSMs for lchans; add inter-BSC HO Add FSMs: - timeslot_fsm: handle dynamic timeslots and OML+RSL availability. - lchan_fsm: handle an individual lchan activation, RTP stream and release, signal the appropriate calling FSMs on success, failure, release. - mgw_endpoint_fsm: handle one entire endpoint with several CI. - assignment_fsm: BSSMAP Assignment Request. - handover_fsm: all of intra, inter-MO and inter-MT handover. Above FSMs absorb large parts of the gscon FSM. The gscon FSM was surpassing the maximum amount events (32), and it is more logical to treat assignment, handover and MGW procedures in separate FSMs. - Add logging macros for each FSM type: - LOG_TS() - LOG_LCHAN() - LOG_MGWEP(), LOG_CI() - LOG_ASSIGNMENT() - LOG_HO() These log with the osmo_fsm_inst where present. New style decision: logging without a final newline char is awkward, especially for gsmtap logging and when other logs interleave LOGPC() calls; we have various cases where the final \n goes missing, and also this invokes the log category checking N times instead of once. So I decided to make these macros *always* append a newline, but only if there is no final newline yet. I hope that the compiler optimizes the strlen() of the constant format strings away. Thus I can log with or without typing "\n" and always get an \n termination anyway. General: - replace osmo_timers, state enums and program-wide osmo_signal_dispatch() with dedicated FSM timeouts, states and events. - introduce a common way to handle Tnnn timers: gsm_timers.h/.c: struct T_def. These can be used (with some macro magic) to define a state's timeout once, and not make mistakes for each osmo_fsm_inst_state_chg(). Details: bsc_subscr_conn_fsm.c: - move most states of this FSM to lchan_fsm, assignment_fsm, handover_fsm and mgw_endpoint_fsm. - There is exactly one state for an ongoing Assignment, with all details handled in conn->assignment.fi. The state relies on the assignment_fsm's timeout. - There is one state for an ongoing Handover; except for an incoming Handover from a remote BSS, the gscon remains in ST_INIT until the new lchan and conn are both established. - move bssmap_add_lcls_status() to osmo_bsc_lcls.c abis_rsl.c: - move all dynamic timeslot logic away into timeslot_fsm. Only keep plain send/receive functions in abis_rsl.c - reduce some rsl functions to merely send a message, rename to "_tx_". - rsl_ipacc_mdcx(): add '_tx_' in the name; move parts that change the lchan state out into the lchan_fsm, the lchan->abis_ip.* are now set there prior to invoking this function. - move all timers and error/release handling away into various FSMs. - tweak ipa_smod_s_for_lchan() and ipa_rtp_pt_for_lchan() to not require an lchan passed, but just mode,type that they require. Rename to ipacc_speech_mode*() and ipacc_payload_type(). - add rsl_forward_layer3_info, used for inter-BSC HO MO, to just send the RR message received during BSSMAP Handover Command. - move various logging to LOG_LCHAN() in order to log with the lchan FSM instance. One drawback is that the lchan FSM is limited to one logging category, i.e. this moves some logging from DRR to DRSL. It might actually make sense to combine those categories. - lose LOGP...LOGPC logging cascades: they are bad for gsmtap logging and for performance. - handle_classmark_chg(): change logging, move cm2 len check out of the cm3 condition (I hope that's correct). - gsm48_send_ho_cmd(): split off gsm48_make_ho_cmd() which doesn't send right away, so that during inter-bsc HO we can make an RR Handover Command to send via the MSC to the remote BSS. assignment_fsm.c: - the Chan Mode Modify in case of re-using the same lchan is not implemented yet, because this was also missing in the previous implementation (OS#3357). osmo_bsc_api.c: - simplify bsc_mr_config() and move to lchan_fsm.c, the only caller; rename to lchan_mr_config(). (bsc_mr_config() used to copy the values to mr_bts_lv twice, once by member assignment and then again with a memcpy.) - During handover, we used to copy the MR config from the old lchan. Since we may handover between FR and HR, rather set the MR Config anew every time, so that FR rates are always available on FR lchans, and never on HR lchans. Depends: I03ee7ce840ecfa0b6a33358e7385528aabd4873f (libosmocore), I1f2918418c38918c5ac70acaa51a47adfca12b5e (libosmocore) Change-Id: I82e3f918295daa83274a4cf803f046979f284366
2018-05-14 16:14:15 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/lchan_fsm.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/lchan_rtp_fsm.o \
large refactoring: use FSMs for lchans; add inter-BSC HO Add FSMs: - timeslot_fsm: handle dynamic timeslots and OML+RSL availability. - lchan_fsm: handle an individual lchan activation, RTP stream and release, signal the appropriate calling FSMs on success, failure, release. - mgw_endpoint_fsm: handle one entire endpoint with several CI. - assignment_fsm: BSSMAP Assignment Request. - handover_fsm: all of intra, inter-MO and inter-MT handover. Above FSMs absorb large parts of the gscon FSM. The gscon FSM was surpassing the maximum amount events (32), and it is more logical to treat assignment, handover and MGW procedures in separate FSMs. - Add logging macros for each FSM type: - LOG_TS() - LOG_LCHAN() - LOG_MGWEP(), LOG_CI() - LOG_ASSIGNMENT() - LOG_HO() These log with the osmo_fsm_inst where present. New style decision: logging without a final newline char is awkward, especially for gsmtap logging and when other logs interleave LOGPC() calls; we have various cases where the final \n goes missing, and also this invokes the log category checking N times instead of once. So I decided to make these macros *always* append a newline, but only if there is no final newline yet. I hope that the compiler optimizes the strlen() of the constant format strings away. Thus I can log with or without typing "\n" and always get an \n termination anyway. General: - replace osmo_timers, state enums and program-wide osmo_signal_dispatch() with dedicated FSM timeouts, states and events. - introduce a common way to handle Tnnn timers: gsm_timers.h/.c: struct T_def. These can be used (with some macro magic) to define a state's timeout once, and not make mistakes for each osmo_fsm_inst_state_chg(). Details: bsc_subscr_conn_fsm.c: - move most states of this FSM to lchan_fsm, assignment_fsm, handover_fsm and mgw_endpoint_fsm. - There is exactly one state for an ongoing Assignment, with all details handled in conn->assignment.fi. The state relies on the assignment_fsm's timeout. - There is one state for an ongoing Handover; except for an incoming Handover from a remote BSS, the gscon remains in ST_INIT until the new lchan and conn are both established. - move bssmap_add_lcls_status() to osmo_bsc_lcls.c abis_rsl.c: - move all dynamic timeslot logic away into timeslot_fsm. Only keep plain send/receive functions in abis_rsl.c - reduce some rsl functions to merely send a message, rename to "_tx_". - rsl_ipacc_mdcx(): add '_tx_' in the name; move parts that change the lchan state out into the lchan_fsm, the lchan->abis_ip.* are now set there prior to invoking this function. - move all timers and error/release handling away into various FSMs. - tweak ipa_smod_s_for_lchan() and ipa_rtp_pt_for_lchan() to not require an lchan passed, but just mode,type that they require. Rename to ipacc_speech_mode*() and ipacc_payload_type(). - add rsl_forward_layer3_info, used for inter-BSC HO MO, to just send the RR message received during BSSMAP Handover Command. - move various logging to LOG_LCHAN() in order to log with the lchan FSM instance. One drawback is that the lchan FSM is limited to one logging category, i.e. this moves some logging from DRR to DRSL. It might actually make sense to combine those categories. - lose LOGP...LOGPC logging cascades: they are bad for gsmtap logging and for performance. - handle_classmark_chg(): change logging, move cm2 len check out of the cm3 condition (I hope that's correct). - gsm48_send_ho_cmd(): split off gsm48_make_ho_cmd() which doesn't send right away, so that during inter-bsc HO we can make an RR Handover Command to send via the MSC to the remote BSS. assignment_fsm.c: - the Chan Mode Modify in case of re-using the same lchan is not implemented yet, because this was also missing in the previous implementation (OS#3357). osmo_bsc_api.c: - simplify bsc_mr_config() and move to lchan_fsm.c, the only caller; rename to lchan_mr_config(). (bsc_mr_config() used to copy the values to mr_bts_lv twice, once by member assignment and then again with a memcpy.) - During handover, we used to copy the MR config from the old lchan. Since we may handover between FR and HR, rather set the MR Config anew every time, so that FR rates are always available on FR lchans, and never on HR lchans. Depends: I03ee7ce840ecfa0b6a33358e7385528aabd4873f (libosmocore), I1f2918418c38918c5ac70acaa51a47adfca12b5e (libosmocore) Change-Id: I82e3f918295daa83274a4cf803f046979f284366
2018-05-14 16:14:15 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/lchan_select.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/meas_feed.o \
dissolve libbsc: move all to src/osmo-bsc, link .o files Move all of libbsc/ into osmo-bsc/, and separate/move some implementations to allow linking from utils/* and ipaccess/* without pulling in unccessary dependencies. Some utilities use gsm_network and gsm_bts structs, which already include data structures for fairly advanced uses. Move initialization that only osmo-bsc needs into new bsc_network_init() and bsc_bts_alloc_register() functions, so that the leaner tools can use the old gsm_* versions without the need to link everything (e.g. handover and lchan alloc code). In some instances, there need to be stubs if to cut off linking "just before the RSL level" and prevent dependencies from creeping in. - abis_rsl_rcvmsg(): the only program currently interpreting RSL messages is osmo-bsc, the utils are merely concerned with OML, if at all. - paging_flush_bts(): ip.access nanobts models call this when the RSL link is dropped. Only osmo-bsc actually needs to do anything there. - on_gsm_ts_init(): the mechanism to trigger timeslot initialization is related to OML, while this action to take on init would pull in RSL dependencies. utils/ and ipaccess/ each have a stubs.c file to implement these stubs. Tests implement stubs inline where required. From src/utils/, src/ipaccess/ and tests/*/, link in .o files from osmo-bsc/. In order for this to work, the osmo-bsc subdir must be built before the other source trees. (An alternative would be to include the .c files as sources, but that would re-compile them in every source tree. Not a large burden really, but unless linking .o files gives problems, let's have the quicker build.) Minor obvious cleanups creep in with this patch, I will not bother to name them individually now unless code review asks me to. Rationale: 1) libbsc has been separate to use it for osmo-nitb and osmo-bsc in the old openbsc.git. This is no longer required, and spreading over libbsc and osmo-bsc is distracting. 2) Recently, ridiculous linking requirements have made adding new functions cumbersome, because libbsc has started depending on osmo-bsc/*.c implementations: on gscon FSM and bssap functions. For example, neither bs11_config nor ipaccess-config nor bts_test need handover_cfg or BSSMAP message composition. It makes no sense to link the entire osmo-bsc to it, nor do we want to keep adding stubs to each linking realm. Change-Id: I36a586726f5818121abe54d25654819fc451d3bf
2018-05-26 23:26:31 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/meas_rep.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/neighbor_ident.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/neighbor_ident_vty.o \
dissolve libbsc: move all to src/osmo-bsc, link .o files Move all of libbsc/ into osmo-bsc/, and separate/move some implementations to allow linking from utils/* and ipaccess/* without pulling in unccessary dependencies. Some utilities use gsm_network and gsm_bts structs, which already include data structures for fairly advanced uses. Move initialization that only osmo-bsc needs into new bsc_network_init() and bsc_bts_alloc_register() functions, so that the leaner tools can use the old gsm_* versions without the need to link everything (e.g. handover and lchan alloc code). In some instances, there need to be stubs if to cut off linking "just before the RSL level" and prevent dependencies from creeping in. - abis_rsl_rcvmsg(): the only program currently interpreting RSL messages is osmo-bsc, the utils are merely concerned with OML, if at all. - paging_flush_bts(): ip.access nanobts models call this when the RSL link is dropped. Only osmo-bsc actually needs to do anything there. - on_gsm_ts_init(): the mechanism to trigger timeslot initialization is related to OML, while this action to take on init would pull in RSL dependencies. utils/ and ipaccess/ each have a stubs.c file to implement these stubs. Tests implement stubs inline where required. From src/utils/, src/ipaccess/ and tests/*/, link in .o files from osmo-bsc/. In order for this to work, the osmo-bsc subdir must be built before the other source trees. (An alternative would be to include the .c files as sources, but that would re-compile them in every source tree. Not a large burden really, but unless linking .o files gives problems, let's have the quicker build.) Minor obvious cleanups creep in with this patch, I will not bother to name them individually now unless code review asks me to. Rationale: 1) libbsc has been separate to use it for osmo-nitb and osmo-bsc in the old openbsc.git. This is no longer required, and spreading over libbsc and osmo-bsc is distracting. 2) Recently, ridiculous linking requirements have made adding new functions cumbersome, because libbsc has started depending on osmo-bsc/*.c implementations: on gscon FSM and bssap functions. For example, neither bs11_config nor ipaccess-config nor bts_test need handover_cfg or BSSMAP message composition. It makes no sense to link the entire osmo-bsc to it, nor do we want to keep adding stubs to each linking realm. Change-Id: I36a586726f5818121abe54d25654819fc451d3bf
2018-05-26 23:26:31 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/net_init.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/osmo_bsc_ctrl.o \
large refactoring: use FSMs for lchans; add inter-BSC HO Add FSMs: - timeslot_fsm: handle dynamic timeslots and OML+RSL availability. - lchan_fsm: handle an individual lchan activation, RTP stream and release, signal the appropriate calling FSMs on success, failure, release. - mgw_endpoint_fsm: handle one entire endpoint with several CI. - assignment_fsm: BSSMAP Assignment Request. - handover_fsm: all of intra, inter-MO and inter-MT handover. Above FSMs absorb large parts of the gscon FSM. The gscon FSM was surpassing the maximum amount events (32), and it is more logical to treat assignment, handover and MGW procedures in separate FSMs. - Add logging macros for each FSM type: - LOG_TS() - LOG_LCHAN() - LOG_MGWEP(), LOG_CI() - LOG_ASSIGNMENT() - LOG_HO() These log with the osmo_fsm_inst where present. New style decision: logging without a final newline char is awkward, especially for gsmtap logging and when other logs interleave LOGPC() calls; we have various cases where the final \n goes missing, and also this invokes the log category checking N times instead of once. So I decided to make these macros *always* append a newline, but only if there is no final newline yet. I hope that the compiler optimizes the strlen() of the constant format strings away. Thus I can log with or without typing "\n" and always get an \n termination anyway. General: - replace osmo_timers, state enums and program-wide osmo_signal_dispatch() with dedicated FSM timeouts, states and events. - introduce a common way to handle Tnnn timers: gsm_timers.h/.c: struct T_def. These can be used (with some macro magic) to define a state's timeout once, and not make mistakes for each osmo_fsm_inst_state_chg(). Details: bsc_subscr_conn_fsm.c: - move most states of this FSM to lchan_fsm, assignment_fsm, handover_fsm and mgw_endpoint_fsm. - There is exactly one state for an ongoing Assignment, with all details handled in conn->assignment.fi. The state relies on the assignment_fsm's timeout. - There is one state for an ongoing Handover; except for an incoming Handover from a remote BSS, the gscon remains in ST_INIT until the new lchan and conn are both established. - move bssmap_add_lcls_status() to osmo_bsc_lcls.c abis_rsl.c: - move all dynamic timeslot logic away into timeslot_fsm. Only keep plain send/receive functions in abis_rsl.c - reduce some rsl functions to merely send a message, rename to "_tx_". - rsl_ipacc_mdcx(): add '_tx_' in the name; move parts that change the lchan state out into the lchan_fsm, the lchan->abis_ip.* are now set there prior to invoking this function. - move all timers and error/release handling away into various FSMs. - tweak ipa_smod_s_for_lchan() and ipa_rtp_pt_for_lchan() to not require an lchan passed, but just mode,type that they require. Rename to ipacc_speech_mode*() and ipacc_payload_type(). - add rsl_forward_layer3_info, used for inter-BSC HO MO, to just send the RR message received during BSSMAP Handover Command. - move various logging to LOG_LCHAN() in order to log with the lchan FSM instance. One drawback is that the lchan FSM is limited to one logging category, i.e. this moves some logging from DRR to DRSL. It might actually make sense to combine those categories. - lose LOGP...LOGPC logging cascades: they are bad for gsmtap logging and for performance. - handle_classmark_chg(): change logging, move cm2 len check out of the cm3 condition (I hope that's correct). - gsm48_send_ho_cmd(): split off gsm48_make_ho_cmd() which doesn't send right away, so that during inter-bsc HO we can make an RR Handover Command to send via the MSC to the remote BSS. assignment_fsm.c: - the Chan Mode Modify in case of re-using the same lchan is not implemented yet, because this was also missing in the previous implementation (OS#3357). osmo_bsc_api.c: - simplify bsc_mr_config() and move to lchan_fsm.c, the only caller; rename to lchan_mr_config(). (bsc_mr_config() used to copy the values to mr_bts_lv twice, once by member assignment and then again with a memcpy.) - During handover, we used to copy the MR config from the old lchan. Since we may handover between FR and HR, rather set the MR Config anew every time, so that FR rates are always available on FR lchans, and never on HR lchans. Depends: I03ee7ce840ecfa0b6a33358e7385528aabd4873f (libosmocore), I1f2918418c38918c5ac70acaa51a47adfca12b5e (libosmocore) Change-Id: I82e3f918295daa83274a4cf803f046979f284366
2018-05-14 16:14:15 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/osmo_bsc_lcls.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/osmo_bsc_mgcp.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/osmo_bsc_msc.o \
dissolve libbsc: move all to src/osmo-bsc, link .o files Move all of libbsc/ into osmo-bsc/, and separate/move some implementations to allow linking from utils/* and ipaccess/* without pulling in unccessary dependencies. Some utilities use gsm_network and gsm_bts structs, which already include data structures for fairly advanced uses. Move initialization that only osmo-bsc needs into new bsc_network_init() and bsc_bts_alloc_register() functions, so that the leaner tools can use the old gsm_* versions without the need to link everything (e.g. handover and lchan alloc code). In some instances, there need to be stubs if to cut off linking "just before the RSL level" and prevent dependencies from creeping in. - abis_rsl_rcvmsg(): the only program currently interpreting RSL messages is osmo-bsc, the utils are merely concerned with OML, if at all. - paging_flush_bts(): ip.access nanobts models call this when the RSL link is dropped. Only osmo-bsc actually needs to do anything there. - on_gsm_ts_init(): the mechanism to trigger timeslot initialization is related to OML, while this action to take on init would pull in RSL dependencies. utils/ and ipaccess/ each have a stubs.c file to implement these stubs. Tests implement stubs inline where required. From src/utils/, src/ipaccess/ and tests/*/, link in .o files from osmo-bsc/. In order for this to work, the osmo-bsc subdir must be built before the other source trees. (An alternative would be to include the .c files as sources, but that would re-compile them in every source tree. Not a large burden really, but unless linking .o files gives problems, let's have the quicker build.) Minor obvious cleanups creep in with this patch, I will not bother to name them individually now unless code review asks me to. Rationale: 1) libbsc has been separate to use it for osmo-nitb and osmo-bsc in the old openbsc.git. This is no longer required, and spreading over libbsc and osmo-bsc is distracting. 2) Recently, ridiculous linking requirements have made adding new functions cumbersome, because libbsc has started depending on osmo-bsc/*.c implementations: on gscon FSM and bssap functions. For example, neither bs11_config nor ipaccess-config nor bts_test need handover_cfg or BSSMAP message composition. It makes no sense to link the entire osmo-bsc to it, nor do we want to keep adding stubs to each linking realm. Change-Id: I36a586726f5818121abe54d25654819fc451d3bf
2018-05-26 23:26:31 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/paging.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/pcu_sock.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/penalty_timers.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/rest_octets.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/system_information.o \
large refactoring: use FSMs for lchans; add inter-BSC HO Add FSMs: - timeslot_fsm: handle dynamic timeslots and OML+RSL availability. - lchan_fsm: handle an individual lchan activation, RTP stream and release, signal the appropriate calling FSMs on success, failure, release. - mgw_endpoint_fsm: handle one entire endpoint with several CI. - assignment_fsm: BSSMAP Assignment Request. - handover_fsm: all of intra, inter-MO and inter-MT handover. Above FSMs absorb large parts of the gscon FSM. The gscon FSM was surpassing the maximum amount events (32), and it is more logical to treat assignment, handover and MGW procedures in separate FSMs. - Add logging macros for each FSM type: - LOG_TS() - LOG_LCHAN() - LOG_MGWEP(), LOG_CI() - LOG_ASSIGNMENT() - LOG_HO() These log with the osmo_fsm_inst where present. New style decision: logging without a final newline char is awkward, especially for gsmtap logging and when other logs interleave LOGPC() calls; we have various cases where the final \n goes missing, and also this invokes the log category checking N times instead of once. So I decided to make these macros *always* append a newline, but only if there is no final newline yet. I hope that the compiler optimizes the strlen() of the constant format strings away. Thus I can log with or without typing "\n" and always get an \n termination anyway. General: - replace osmo_timers, state enums and program-wide osmo_signal_dispatch() with dedicated FSM timeouts, states and events. - introduce a common way to handle Tnnn timers: gsm_timers.h/.c: struct T_def. These can be used (with some macro magic) to define a state's timeout once, and not make mistakes for each osmo_fsm_inst_state_chg(). Details: bsc_subscr_conn_fsm.c: - move most states of this FSM to lchan_fsm, assignment_fsm, handover_fsm and mgw_endpoint_fsm. - There is exactly one state for an ongoing Assignment, with all details handled in conn->assignment.fi. The state relies on the assignment_fsm's timeout. - There is one state for an ongoing Handover; except for an incoming Handover from a remote BSS, the gscon remains in ST_INIT until the new lchan and conn are both established. - move bssmap_add_lcls_status() to osmo_bsc_lcls.c abis_rsl.c: - move all dynamic timeslot logic away into timeslot_fsm. Only keep plain send/receive functions in abis_rsl.c - reduce some rsl functions to merely send a message, rename to "_tx_". - rsl_ipacc_mdcx(): add '_tx_' in the name; move parts that change the lchan state out into the lchan_fsm, the lchan->abis_ip.* are now set there prior to invoking this function. - move all timers and error/release handling away into various FSMs. - tweak ipa_smod_s_for_lchan() and ipa_rtp_pt_for_lchan() to not require an lchan passed, but just mode,type that they require. Rename to ipacc_speech_mode*() and ipacc_payload_type(). - add rsl_forward_layer3_info, used for inter-BSC HO MO, to just send the RR message received during BSSMAP Handover Command. - move various logging to LOG_LCHAN() in order to log with the lchan FSM instance. One drawback is that the lchan FSM is limited to one logging category, i.e. this moves some logging from DRR to DRSL. It might actually make sense to combine those categories. - lose LOGP...LOGPC logging cascades: they are bad for gsmtap logging and for performance. - handle_classmark_chg(): change logging, move cm2 len check out of the cm3 condition (I hope that's correct). - gsm48_send_ho_cmd(): split off gsm48_make_ho_cmd() which doesn't send right away, so that during inter-bsc HO we can make an RR Handover Command to send via the MSC to the remote BSS. assignment_fsm.c: - the Chan Mode Modify in case of re-using the same lchan is not implemented yet, because this was also missing in the previous implementation (OS#3357). osmo_bsc_api.c: - simplify bsc_mr_config() and move to lchan_fsm.c, the only caller; rename to lchan_mr_config(). (bsc_mr_config() used to copy the values to mr_bts_lv twice, once by member assignment and then again with a memcpy.) - During handover, we used to copy the MR config from the old lchan. Since we may handover between FR and HR, rather set the MR Config anew every time, so that FR rates are always available on FR lchans, and never on HR lchans. Depends: I03ee7ce840ecfa0b6a33358e7385528aabd4873f (libosmocore), I1f2918418c38918c5ac70acaa51a47adfca12b5e (libosmocore) Change-Id: I82e3f918295daa83274a4cf803f046979f284366
2018-05-14 16:14:15 +00:00
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/timeslot_fsm.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/smscb.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/cbch_scheduler.o \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/cbsp_link.o \
$(LIBOSMOCORE_LIBS) \
$(LIBOSMOGSM_LIBS) \
$(LIBOSMOCTRL_LIBS) \
$(LIBOSMOVTY_LIBS) \
$(LIBOSMOABIS_LIBS) \
$(LIBOSMONETIF_LIBS) \
introduce an osmo_fsm for gsm_subscriber_connection In the current implementation of osmo-bsc, the subscriber connection is not handled (very) statefully. However, there is some state keeping in the code that handles the mgcp connection, but there are still to much loose ends which allow odd situations to happen, which then lead severe error situations (see also closes tags at the end) This commit adds a number of improvements to fix those problems. - Use an osmo-fsm to control the gsm_subscriber_connection state and make sure that certain operations can only take place at certain states (e.g let connection oriented SCCP traffic only pass when an SCCP connection actually exists. Remove the old osmo_bsc_mgcp.c code. Use the recently developed MGCP client FSM to handle the MGCP connections. Also make sure that stuff that already works does not break. This in particular refers to the internal handover capability and the respective unit-tests. See also OS#2823, OS#2768 and OS#2898 - Fix logic to permit assignment to a signalling channel. (OS#2762) - Introduce T993210 to release lchan + subscr_conn if MSC fails to respond The GSM specs don't have an explicit timer for this, so let's introdcue a custom timer (hence starting with 99). This timeout catches the following situation: * we send a SCCP CR with COMPL_L3_INFO from the MS to the MSC, * the MSC doesn't respond (e.g. SCCP routing failure, program down, ...) The MS is supposed to timeout with T3210, 3220 or 3230. But the BSC shouldn't trust the MS but have some timer on its own. SCCP would have a timer T(conn est), but that one is specified to be 1-2min and hence rather long. See also: OS#2775 - Terminate bsc_subscr_conn_fsm on SCCP N-DISC.ind from MSC If the MSC is disconnecting the SCCP channel, we must terminate the FSM which in turn will release all lchan's and other state. This makes TC_chan_rel_hard_rlsd pass, see also OS#2731 As a side-effect, this fixes TC_chan_act_ack_est_ind_refused(), where the MSC is answering with CREF to our CR/COMPL_L3. - Release subscriber connection on RLL RELEASE IND of SAPI0 on main DCCH The subscriber connection isn't really useful for anything after the SAPI0 main signalling link has been released. We could try to re-establish, but our best option is probably simply releasing the subscriber_conn and anything related to it. This will make TC_chan_rel_rll_rel_ind pass, see also OS#2730 This commit has been tested using the BSC_Tests TTCN3 testsuit and the following tests were passed: TC_chan_act_noreply TC_chan_act_ack_noest TC_chan_act_ack_est_ind_noreply TC_chan_act_ack_est_ind_refused TC_chan_act_nack TC_chan_exhaustion TC_ctrl TC_chan_rel_conn_fail TC_chan_rel_hard_clear TC_chan_rel_hard_rlsd TC_chan_rel_a_reset TC_rll_est_ind_inact_lchan TC_rll_est_ind_inval_sapi1 TC_rll_est_ind_inval_sapi3 TC_rll_est_ind_inval_sacch TC_assignment_cic_only TC_assignment_csd TC_assignment_ctm TC_assignment_fr_a5_0 TC_assignment_fr_a5_1_codec_missing TC_assignment_fr_a5_1 TC_assignment_fr_a5_3 TC_assignment_fr_a5_4 TC_paging_imsi_nochan TC_paging_tmsi_nochan TC_paging_tmsi_any TC_paging_tmsi_sdcch TC_paging_tmsi_tch_f TC_paging_tmsi_tch_hf TC_paging_imsi_nochan_cgi TC_paging_imsi_nochan_lac_ci TC_paging_imsi_nochan_ci TC_paging_imsi_nochan_lai TC_paging_imsi_nochan_lac TC_paging_imsi_nochan_all TC_paging_imsi_nochan_plmn_lac_rnc TC_paging_imsi_nochan_rnc TC_paging_imsi_nochan_lac_rnc TC_paging_imsi_nochan_lacs TC_paging_imsi_nochan_lacs_empty TC_paging_imsi_a_reset TC_paging_counter TC_rsl_drop_counter TC_classmark TC_unsol_ass_fail TC_unsol_ass_compl TC_unsol_ho_fail TC_err_82_short_msg TC_ho_int Authors: Harald Welte <laforge@gnumonks.org> Philipp Maier <pmaier@sysmocom.de> Neels Hofmeyr <neels@hofmeyr.de> Closes: OS#2730 Closes: OS#2731 Closes: OS#2762 Closes: OS#2768 Closes: OS#2775 Closes: OS#2823 Closes: OS#2898 Closes: OS#2936 Change-Id: I68286d26e2014048b054f39ef29c35fef420cc97
2018-01-28 02:04:16 +00:00
$(LIBOSMOSIGTRAN_LIBS) \
$(LIBOSMOMGCPCLIENT_LIBS) \
$(NULL)
neighbor_ident_test_SOURCES = \
neighbor_ident_test.c \
$(NULL)
neighbor_ident_test_LDADD = \
$(top_builddir)/src/osmo-bsc/neighbor_ident.o \
$(LIBOSMOCORE_LIBS) \
$(LIBOSMOGSM_LIBS) \
$(LIBOSMOCTRL_LIBS) \
$(NULL)
.PHONY: update_exp
update_exp:
$(builddir)/neighbor_ident_test >$(srcdir)/neighbor_ident_test.ok 2>$(srcdir)/neighbor_ident_test.err