Fixes: Jenkins build #609 warning
Addresses:
llc.cpp:56, GNU C Compiler 3 (gcc), Priority: Normal
comparison between signed and unsigned integer expressions
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently the slot selection of algorithm A is based on the current
slot usage by active TBF. Especially in the Dl after UL case which
reflects the commen use case "MS initiates TCP connection", the
resulting distribution is not optimal with respect to PDCH usage.
This commit changes the implementation to use the slot reservation
information instead.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently when using the test modes TEST_MODE_DL_AFTER_UL or
TEST_MODE_UL_AFTER_DL, the first TBF is deleted before the second is
allocated. The far more interesting case were to keep the first TBF a
little bit longer until the second TBF has been created and delete
then. This comes closer the the situation observed with real MS,
where the first TBF takes some time (timeout or waiting for Ack)
before it gets deleted and thus detached from the MS object.
This commit delays the call to tbf_free accordingly.
The effect can be observed in the results of the algo A tests, where
the uniform distribution of the allocated PDCH is lost.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently the search for an enabled PDCH slot for SBA start with the
first TS. If there are more than 2 PDCH slots enabled, this slot will
conflict with an existing multislot reservation for most multislot
classes. This were less likely if the search were reversed and
started with the last slot due to the 3 slot shift between Tx and Rx.
When multislot allocation is enabled and several MS are connected,
and increased rate of poll timeouts can be observed.
This commit tries to reduce the number of poll timeouts by reverting
the slot search order for SBA allocation.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
The current logging statements within the inner loop of
find_multi_slots drain quite a lot of CPU resources even if
LOGL_DEBUG is not enabled. This might cause issues on the target
hardware.
This commit disables these LOGP calls unless the
ENABLE_TS_ALLOC_DEBUG macro has been set explicitly. This results in
a reduction in the CPU usage reported by callgrind for
find_multi_slots from 42% to 25% when executing AllocTest.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
According to callgrind, this function consumes 33% CPU when running
the AllocTest program.
This commit uses the assigned_usf() method to get the USFs allocated
by a PDCH instead of traversing the TBFs.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently is is rather expensive to get TFI and USF usage per PDCH,
because the TBFs need to be scanned to get that information.
This commit adds corresponding bit sets which get updated by the
attach_tbf/detach_tbf methods of the gprs_rlcmac_pdch class.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently the search of the "best" slot combination is done
separately from the UL slot selection, which can lead to an
allocation failure due to USF exhaustion even if another combination
had been possible.
This commit reduces the probability for this event by skipping UL
slots without free USF while calculation the capacity.
Note that the implementation is rather inefficient which will be
fixed by the following commits.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Since currently the algorithm B will only allocate a single UL slot
and will have to stick to it (first common TS), the other possible UL
slots will not be allocated while the reservation is kept.
This commit adds code to update the reserved set of UL slots to only
reserve the single common TS when the UL TBF is allocated.
Interestingly this leads to fewer allocated TBF in some cases due to
USF exhaustion. This will be improved by the following commit "alloc:
Skip common TS without free USF".
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently the capacity of a PDCH slot is calculated as 32 - N_reserved
for each direction. This can result in a capacity of 0 and even
negative values.
This commit forces the capacity of an usable slot to be at least zero
under the assumption, that an overly reserved PDCH is still better
than none.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently al possible UL slots are included in the capacity
calculation which is the base of the slot selection. Nevertheless
UL-only slots will never be used, since only one uplink slot (which
must be a common slot) will be used.
This patch changes the code to only include common slots in the
capacity sum.
Note that this might not be optimal if algorithm B supported
multiple uplink slots.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
The current implementation always starts the downlink slot allocation
with the first possible slot, depending on which channels are enabled
and which multislot class is offered by the MS. So in configurations
with many (>4) PDCH, some PDCH are not really used.
The new implementation introduced by this commit differs as follows:
- The reservation mechanism provided by GprsMs is used to avoid
incompatibilities is used in the same way like algo A does. This
basically means, that the allocation is done once when the first
TBF is requested and then used until all TBF have been released.
- All combinations of Rx and Tx slots are checked for compatibility
with the multiscot class. Basically the combination with the most
usable PDCH and the least number of reservations is used.
- Only one UL slots is provided.
- Tta and Tra are checked.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
This commits adds three poll timeout counters
- RLC Assign Timeout
- RLC Ack Timeout
- RLC Release Timeout
to help diagnosing to cause for these events. There seems to be an
increased rate of these when a PDCH is shared by multiple TBFs.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
This reverts commit 2272a83a13b57ea7e99fe96ac76e4ad892e19e90.
The modification is no longer needed, since the call to update has
been removed from reuse_tbf().
Conflicts:
src/tbf_dl.cpp
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Since both TBF are based on the same reservation which means that
they should be compatible with respect to the slot usage, and since
the new TBF has not been forced to single slot usage, an update of
the allocation is not necessary now.
This commit removes the call to update() from within reuse_tbf().
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
The call to tbf_alloc_dl_tbf misses the pointer to the GprsMs object
which is already known in that case (tbf_reuse). This leads to a full
reallocation of the PDCH slots, which is possibly incompatible with
the old set of slots. This can result in hanging TCP connections and
TCP connection failures.
This commit replaces the old NULL value by the actual GprsMs object.
Since the set_ms() is also done within the tbf_alloc_dl_tbf method,
that call is removed.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently algorithm A bases its time slots selection on the number of
TBF actively using the PDCHs. This statistically prefers the first
time slots, especially with short living TBFs. So when the first TBF
is triggered by an uplink transfer (which generally results in a
short-lived TBF) the potentially longer living DL TBF will be bound
to the same slot. When another MS then requests an uplink TBF, it
will get the same slot (no UL TBF currently active).
This commit changes the algorithm to base its selection on reserved
slots instead.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
According to TS 45.002, 6.4.2 the training sequence (TSC) must be the
same for all slots in a multi-slot set.
This commit updates find_possible_pdchs() to only consider slots with
the same TSC if more that 1 slot shall be assigned.
Note that the first PDCH's TSC will be used as reference, so if two
or more groups with a common TSC are configured, only the first will
be used. This restriction does not apply to algorithm A, since it
will not assign more than one slot and therefore sets the max_slots
parameter to 1.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
In contrast to the slots currently used by existing TBFs, the
reserved slots refer to the time slots that can be used for newly
allocated TBFs without causing conflicts (given that the first common
TS does not change). They correspond to the potential use of the
PDCHs and can be used to achieve a more uniform slot allocation.
This commit adds bit set based methods to GprsMs and gprs_rlcmac_trx
and a counter to gprs_rlcmac_pdch. The current TRX will also be
stored in the MS object.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently only the first enabled PDCH will be used. Beside the
throughput this will also limit the number of TBFs:
- number of UL TBFs <= 7
- number of DL TBFs <= 32
This commit changes the allocation algorithm to use the PDCH with the
least number of attached TBFs. This will improve the troughput in
both directions and the UL limits:
- number of UL TBFs <= min(32, N_PDCH * 7) UL TBFs
Ticket: #1794
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Since set_ms() is caled on the new DL TBF, the old DL TBF loses the
reference to the MS object. This will lead to a segfault, when
update() is called in reuse_tbf().
This commit adds an optional GprsMs* parameter to update() and uses it
for the slot allocation.
This fixes a TbfTest crash that would otherwise occur after applying
the next commit.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
To avoid the need for a switch or conditional statement when needing
a TBF from an MS object in direction independant code, this method
contains that case distinction. For additional flexibility, a
reverse() function is added to get the opposite direction.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
This method gets the index (0 based) of first common time slot used
by the TBFs attach to it. It expects that all of them have the same
notion of this. If no TBF is attached, -1 will be returned.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently the PDCH object do not know anything about the TBFs using
them. To make the slot allocation load dependant, at least some
numbers are required.
This commit adds TBF counters (one per direction) and the related methods
attach_tbf, detach_tbf, and num_tbfs to gprs_rlcmac_pdch.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
When this environment variable is set, the logging level is set to
LOGL_DEBUG to help debugging without putting everything into
AllocTest.err.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
This commit adds:
- an assertion to check that count is valid,
- an assertion the verify that tbf_alloc did not fail
- a slots parameter to specify the enabled slots
- additional test invocations with more slots enabled
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
This test allocates as many as possible UL/DL TBF pairs, shows their
PDCH usage, and checks how many of them has been created
successfully.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently the code that creates the MS objects with tbf.cpp is
duplicated.
This commit moves the corresponding code into a new method. Since
there is no TLLI available there, the GprsMsStorage::create_ms method
has been refactored into two variants: one with TLLI/direction and
one without.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently the MS object are created when the TLLI gets known.
Therefore some information (TA, MS class) must be stored in the TBF
itself and is copied to the MS object later on. This would get even
more complex, if the allocation algorithms were extended based on
this scheme.
This commit ensures, that an MS object will always be created on TBF
allocation, even if the TLLI is not yet known. These 'anonymous'
objects are still managed by the MS storage. To avoid dangling
entries without a TLLI there (which cannnot be retrieved anyway), the
timer in the MS objects is not started after all TBF have been
detached, so that they get deleted immediately in that case.
Note that an MS object can still be removed (e.g. by replacement)
from an existing TBF, so tbf->ms() can be NULL.
Ticket: #1794
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently the old TBF (either uplink or downlink) is passed around at
TBF allocation mainly to get information about the MS. To implement
more complex allocation algorithms, the MS object itself will be
needed anyway.
This commit replaces the old_tbf arguments by MS object arguments.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
This method does not do anything anymore, it's functionality has been
taken over by update_ms.
This commit removes gprs_rlcmac_tbf::update_tlli completely.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Using complex initialiser lists doesn't seem to work well with Debian
Squeeze.
This commit changes the initialisation to use separate assignments
instead.
Fixes: Jenkins #601, #602
Addresses:
CXX LlcTest.o
../../tests/llc/LlcTest.cpp: In function 'void test_llc_meta()':
../../tests/llc/LlcTest.cpp:137: error: expected primary-expression
before '.' token
../../tests/llc/LlcTest.cpp:137: warning: extended initializer
lists only available with -std=c++0x or -std=gnu++0x
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
To support extended initialiser lists some platforms (at least debian
squeeze) require to add -std=c++0x or -std=gnu++0x to CXXFLAGS. While
that option is deprecated on newer platforms (at least gcc 4.8) this
options is still supported on every platform currently in use.
This commit adds -std=gnu++0x to the CXXFLAGS used to compile
LlcTest.cpp.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
While including time.h is sufficient with Ubuntu's current libc6
2.19, the correct (and portable) include file is sys/time.h.
This commit modifies the include directive in llc.h accordingly.
Fixes: Jenkins #600
Addresses:
In file included from gprs_ms.h:28,
from gprs_ms.cpp:22:
llc.h:68: error: field 'recv_time' has incomplete type
llc.h:69: error: field 'expire_time' has incomplete type
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently the receive and expiry timestamps are prepended to the LLC
msgb before it is passed to gprs_llc_queue::enqueue(). Since this meta
information should not be counted as LLC octets, the gprs_llc_queue
needs to known about this (unless the correction was done in the LLC
layer).
This commit moves the meta information storage code into
gprs_llc_queue. The meta data is now stored in the control block
(cb) area of the msgb.
Note that the info pointer that is returned from the dequeue method
is only valid if that method returns a (non-NULL) msgb. It must not
be used after that msgb has been modified or freed.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Some struct timeval pointer arguments do not have the const qualifier,
albeit the methods do not write to the structures. The next commit
will change related pointers to const, so this commit provides the
required constness.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
If just a few bytes are left to send to the MS, it makes sense to
reduce the coding scheme level to increase the throughput. This
has been shown by Chen and Goodman in their paper "Theoretical
Analysis of GPRS Throughput and Delay". See their throughput over C/I
measurement graphs (figures 4 and 5 in the paper) for details.
This commit implements a simplified CS downgrade feature for the
downlink. The coding scheme will be downgraded if there are only a
few octets are left to be send over the TBF (see the
downgrade-threshold command below) and the NACK rate is not low (the
CS will not get degraded on a high quality RF link). As an exception,
CS-3 will be degraded to CS-1, since CS-2 does not improve the
throughput in general when a few small packets are sent and the
signal fades slowly (see Chen/Goodman).
The following VTY command is added to the config-pcu node:
- cs downgrade-threshold <1-10000>
- cs no downgrade-threshold
to set the threshold of the number of remaining bytes to be RLC/MAC
encoded. The CS will only be reduced, if the number is below the
threshold. The 'no' command disables this feature completely. The
default value is 200 octets.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
To get the number of LLC octets that are stored in the queue, this
commit adds a m_queue_octets member along with a octets() method.
This value is updated similarly to m_queue_size on each modifying
method call.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently struct llist_head is used without declaration which
accidently did not produce an error so far.
This commit adds the missing include directive.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
When the MS is pinged with a longer interval, many packets get lost
even if the GprsMs object is kept. If the interval is above the time
where the DL TBF is in state FLOW (mainly influenced be the
dl-tbf-idle-time command), an new TBF must be requested via AGCH for
each ICMP PING message.
Currently the LLC frame containing the PING is immediately stored
in the TBF and gets lost, if TBF establishment fails for some reason.
This commit moves all calls to put_frame() to schedule_next_frame(),
where the data is moved from the LLC queue to the frame storage
within the TBF object. This method is only called from within
create_new_bsn() when the TBF is in the FLOW state and the frame is
going to be encoded immediately.
At all other places, where put_frame() has been called before, the
LLC message is just appended to the LLC queue in the GprsMs object.
This change effectively simplifies the related code parts, since
date/len information and discard notifications is no longer needed
there.
Ticket: #1759
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently LLC frames are lost or even reordered when the TBF has be
established via the AGCH and the procedure fails for some reason.
This test tries to reproduce this behaviour by throwing away the
first TBF while calling the handle() method several times. The
results of create_dl_acked_block() are checked against expected
values (this is currently party disabled because the bug still
persists).
Ticket: #1759
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Currently the NACK/unconfirmed ratio is already passed to the
corresponding MS object, but the value is not being stored there.
This commit adds a member and a getter method and include the values
into the output of the 'show ms' command.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
The I_LEVEL values that are obtained now look suspicious. They do not
seem to be contained in messages recorded via gsmtab.
To help debugging this issue, this commit adds related debug messages
that are generated while the encoded values are taken from the
RLC/MAC messages.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
This commit extends the pcu_l1_meas structure by MS side measurement
values which are transmitted by PACKET DOWNLINK ACK/NACK and
PACKET RESOURCE REQUEST messages. The encoded values are remapped to
dB respectively % values. The values are stored in the corresponding
MS object (if there is one).
Note that the values are store as (rounded) integers, so some
different encodings are mapped to the same decoded value.
Sponsored-by: On-Waves ehf
Jacob Erlbeck