Give the HLR a chance to send us updated subscriber data by indicating the CN
domain to be Circuit Switched, only during a LU Request GSUP message.
Adjust msc_vlr_tests to expect the added GSUP CN domain IE to indicate CS, i.e.
append '280102'.
Related: OS#3601
Change-Id: I0c2d33fbfdb4728e480679120d06b7f3a2ccfd76
Instead of keeping separate enums for FSM results and translating between those
and the actual 04.08 reject causes that will ultimately reach the MS, just pass
enum gsm48_reject_value cause codes around everywhere.
Collapse some VLR *_timeout() and *_cancel() api to just *_cancel() with a
gsm48 cause arg.
(Hopefully) improve a few reject causes, but otherwise just aim for more
transparent decisions on which cause value is used, for future fixes of
returned causes.
Depends: I6661f139e68a498fb1bef10c266c2f064b72774a (libosmocore)
Change-Id: I27bf8d68737ff1f8dc6d11fb1eac3d391aab0cb1
In the subscr_conn_fsm instance's ID, include the Complete Layer 3 type, so
that we can see on the first glance whether a state transition belongs to MO or
MT.
The huge patch is due to the cosmetic change affecting nearly every single log
line in the msc_vlr_tests, by nature of changing the FSM's ID.
Related: OS#3122
Change-Id: I2a7e27e0f16df1872dcda64cb928c3b8528ea3f7
When sending a BSSMAP Clear or Iu Release, do not immediately discard the conn,
but wait until a BSSMAP Clear Complete / Iu Release Complete has been received.
Hence we will no longer show in the log that an incoming Release/Clear Complete
belongs to an unknown subscriber, but will still be around to properly log the
release.
Related: OS#3122
Change-Id: Ie4c6aaba3866d6e5b98004e8870a215e8cf8ffc1
Refactor:
1. Glue the gsm_subscriber_connection alloc to the subscr_conn_fsm.
2. Add separate AUTH_CIPH state to the FSM.
3. Use conn->use_count to trigger conn release.
4. Add separate RELEASING state to the FSM.
5. Add rate counters for each of the three Complete Layer 3 types.
Details:
1. Glue the gsm_subscriber_connection alloc to the subscr_conn_fsm.
Historically, a gsm_subscriber_connection was allocated in libbsc land, and
only upon Complete Layer 3 did libmsc add the fsm instance. After splitting
openbsc.git into a separate osmo-msc, this is no longer necessary, hence:
Closely tie gsm_subscriber_connection allocation to the subscr_conn_fsm
instance: talloc the conn as a child of the FSM instance, and discard the conn
as soon as the FSM terminates.
2. Add separate AUTH_CIPH state to the FSM.
Decoding the Complete Layer 3 message is distinctly separate from waiting for
the VLR FSMs to conclude. Use the NEW state as "we don't know if this is a
valid message yet", and the AUTH_CIPH state as "evaluating, don't release".
A profound effect of this: should we for any odd reason fail to leave the FSM's
NEW state, the conn will be released right at the end of msc_compl_l3(),
without needing to trigger release in each code path.
3. Use conn->use_count to trigger conn release.
Before, the FSM itself would hold a use count on the conn, and hence we would
need to ask it whether it is ready to release the conn yet by dispatching
events, to achieve a use_count decrement.
Instead, unite the FSM instance and conn, and do not hold a use count by the
FSM. Hence, trigger an FSM "UNUSED" event only when the use_count reaches zero.
As long as use counts are done correctly, the FSM will terminate correctly.
These exceptions:
- The new AUTH_CIPH state explicitly ignores UNUSED events, since we expect the
use count to reach zero while evaluating Authentication and Ciphering. (I
experimented with holding a use count by AUTH_CIPH onenter() and releasing by
onleave(), but the use count and thus the conn are released before the next
state can initiate transactions that would increment the use count again.
Same thing for the VLR FSMs holding a use count, they should be done before
we advance to the next state. The easiest is to simply expect zero use count
during the AUTH_CIPH state.)
- A CM Service Request means that even though the MSC would be through with all
it wants to do, we shall still wait for a request to follow from the MS.
Hence the FSM holds a use count on itself while a CM Service is pending.
- While waiting for a Release/Clear Complete, the FSM holds a use count on
itself.
4. Add separate RELEASING state to the FSM.
If we decide to release for other reasons than a use count reaching zero, we
still need to be able to wait for the msc_dtap() use count on the conn to
release.
(An upcoming patch will further use the RELEASING state to properly wait for
Clear Complete / Release Complete messages.)
5. Add rate counters for each of the three Complete Layer 3 types.
Besides LU, also count CM Service Request and Paging Response
acceptance/rejections. Without these counters, only very few of the auth+ciph
outcomes actually show in the counters.
Related: OS#3122
Change-Id: I55feb379e176a96a831e105b86202b17a0ffe889
So far we hit a running T308 during CC release when caused by a BSSMAP Clear
Request, and we loudly log that as error.
However, now I understand that T308 is a direct cause of the dispatch of a REL
IND towards MNCC, which is used to indicate teardown to MNCC. So during
_gsm48_cc_trans_free(), we first clear all timers, then invoke
mncc_release_ind() which starts another timer (useful for graceful CC Release,
but in this code path the intention is immediate release). Simply immediately
cancel the timer again and release the conn.
A separate question is whether a BSSMAP Clear Request should be less aggressive
in releasing the connections; i.e. instead of calling trans_free() all around,
to rather ask each transaction to "please stop soon", somehow.
Related: OS#3062
Change-Id: I231fdb574a086a206321148474cbdc7ca9cf39f0
Instead of jumping through hoops to pass the Complete Layer 3 operation that
created this conn via FSM event dispatch parameters, put it right in the
gsm_subscriber_connection struct, where it always belonged.
Move definition of the enum complete_layer3_type to gsm_data.h, where
gsm_subscriber_connection is defined.
Introduce msc_subscr_conn_update_id() to set the complete_layer3_type of the
conn as soon as a Complete Layer 3 message is received.
In msc_subscr_conn_update_id(), already include an mi_string argument to
prepare for an upcoming patch where the FSM will be allocated much earlier when
the Mobile Identity is not known yet, and we'll also update the fi->id here.
The odd logging change in the msc_vlr_tests output uncovers a wrong use of the
osmo_fsm_inst_dispatch() data argument for SUBSCR_CONN_E_CN_CLOSE events: if a
child FSM signals unsuccessful result, instead of the failure cause, it passed
the complete_layer3_type, as requested upon FSM allocation, which was then
misinterpreted as a failure cause. Now a child FSM failure will pass NULL
instead, while other SUBSCR_CONN_E_CN_CLOSE events may still pass a valid cause
value.
Related: OS#3122
Change-Id: Iae30dd57a8861c4eaaf56999f872d4e635ba97fb
Since the logging allocations now also show up in the root context report, some
tests need adjusted talloc checks.
In msc_vlr_tests, also output the number of talloc blocks before tests are
started to show that the number didn't change after the tests.
Change-Id: Iae07ae60230c7bab28e52b5df97fa3844778158e
In trans_free(), call subscr_conn_release_when_unused(), so that we are sure to
clean up after the last transaction is done.
This fixes an error where a conn lingered after a CC failure, because that code
path forgot to trigger cleanup.
Rationale: so far we were triggering the release check after each DTAP dispatch
(compl_l3 and "normal" DTAP), which is sufficient for properly closed
transactions. We also need a check for when a timeout clears an erratic trans.
Adjust test expectation of test_call_mo_to_unknown_timeout to show that the
error is now fixed.
msc_vlr_test_reject_concurrency now sees an additional release checking event
when the SMS transaction is done, which is expected and does not affect the
test otherwise.
Related: OS#2779
Change-Id: I46ff2e9b09b67e4e0d79cccf8c04936f17281fcb
These tests helped to debug issue OS#2779. Now that they're here we might as
well keep them.
The test test_call_mo_to_unknown shows that an MS answering to the Release
Request works as it should: the conn is torn down.
The test test_call_mo_to_unknown_timeout currently expects the error: the conn
remains active if the CC Release times out. This bug and the test expectations
will be fixed in I46ff2e9b09b67e4e0d79cccf8c04936f17281fcb.
Change-Id: Ic3c84520bff8c3fc82512d03ff6ab97d21b8fb7a
The naming of "bump" was short and made sense to me at the time of writing, but
it is keeping pretty much everyone else at a distance, no-one intuitively gets
what it is supposed to mean.
Clarify by renaming to "release_when_unused".
Adjust test expectations.
Change-Id: I4dcc55f536f63b13a3da29fff1df5fe16751f83a
There are a number of bad failures in CC teardown handling we're solving. It
helps to see CC logging in the msc_vlr_tests.
Change-Id: I56ac269d46b48b6b85efad81c4d2343bfc41ea90
Also indicate in msc_vlr_test_gsm_authen.c that we're indeed sending no
capability to do R99 in the Classmark 1 during LU request.
Change-Id: Id79a77ca1f218d55dad21d9dd3de92445fb5d6bf
Clearly distinguish between Ciphering Mode Command on GERAN and Security Mode
Control on UTRAN.
Cosmetic: explicitly verify the key strings in the testing code (not only in
the expected output).
Change-Id: Ica93ed06c4c63dc6768736d25231de8068001114
Actually call msc_vlr_set_ciph_mode() and wrap away a_iface_tx_cipher_mode()
and ranap_iu_tx_sec_mode_cmd(). Hence we'll see decisions and errors in
msc_vlr_set_ciph_mode() as well.
Change-Id: Id23bc245d4b5707edcd27c44db272fbb211bf9bd
Three recently merged commits take the msc_vlr_tests in a wrong direction.
The IMSI is usually encoded in the hex streams. The rationale behind hex
streams is that it is a) easily copied from a wireshark trace and b) exactly
the bytes as sent by an actual phone. It is hard to parameterize the IMSI
because we would have to employ our encoding functions, which I intentionally
want to keep out of the loop here.
The test number should not appear in the normal test output, so that adding a
test or changing their order does not affect expected output for following
tests. The nr is simply for manual invocation, only seen when invoked with -v.
Revert
- "VLR tests: always print test parameters"
b0a4314911.
- "Expand VLR tests"
d5feadeee8.
- "Move IMSI into test parameters"
093300d141.
Change-Id: Ie1b49237746751021da88f6f07bbb9f780d077c9
This is another left-over VTY command from the OsmoNITB days.
If such functionality is desired, it must be implemented in OsmoHLR,
but not here.
Related: OS#2528
Change-Id: Icf0897c47388e49ba7886b55acc728a6f7d213fe
For each test print:
* the test number
* IMSI
Unfortunately tests are organized in such a way that we don't know the
number of particular test in advance. Nevertheless, it make sense to
always print it regardless of -v option presense.
Related: OS#2864
Change-Id: I2e1d7701f5322d2311f32b796148a8b414f53b8e
The VLR code seems to have the assumption that there is one particular
algorithm to be used, as opposed to one of a set of algorithms.
What's missing is basically to decide when/where to pick the best
algorithm within the capabilities of the phone (classmark) and the
network configuration (net->a5_encryption_mask). So far, libvlr has no
notion of classmark. Rather, libmsc has.
Why does the VLR care about the particular algorithm at all? The VLR
should probably simply decide if it should use encryption or not, and if
so, the MSC will figure which algorithm to use.
Change-Id: I5ed80ca2086560a5975a758ec568a034a9a8ab89
In I8de7c01f9ea1d66c384e57449c4140186f5ce6c5, libosmocore introduced
shorter names in gsm48_pdisc_names, which has implications on the
expected test output
Change-Id: I4421872a0d609dd50a6b911b928aa5e111d1ad24
* move log helpers to generic header
* log subscriber update
It's handy for troubleshooting issues with subscriber update via GSUP
from HLR.
Change-Id: I1958aeeb3ea99831c7e2c5ee9a6b59834baf4520
Adjust test expectations accordingly.
The error was:
==16084==ERROR: AddressSanitizer: heap-use-after-free on address 0x61500000f5f4 at pc 0x561be639ac2b bp 0x7ffc0aabbe40 sp 0x7ffc0aabbe38
READ of size 4 at 0x61500000f5f4 thread T0
#0 0x561be639ac2a in _msc_subscr_conn_put ../../../../src/osmo-msc/src/libmsc/osmo_msc.c:384
#1 0x561be636070b in rx_from_ms ../../../../src/osmo-msc/tests/msc_vlr/msc_vlr_tests.c:204
#2 0x561be6360b21 in ms_sends_msg ../../../../src/osmo-msc/tests/msc_vlr/msc_vlr_tests.c:217
#3 0x561be635b40a in test_call_mt ../../../../src/osmo-msc/tests/msc_vlr/msc_vlr_test_call.c:328
#4 0x561be6363bb7 in run_tests ../../../../src/osmo-msc/tests/msc_vlr/msc_vlr_tests.c:802
#5 0x561be63524ea in main ../../../../src/osmo-msc/tests/msc_vlr/msc_vlr_tests.c:849
#6 0x7f6eebb3e2b0 in __libc_start_main (/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/libc.so.6+0x202b0)
#7 0x561be6352fb9 in _start (/n/s/osmo/make-3G/osmo-msc/tests/msc_vlr/msc_vlr_test_call+0xdafb9)
Related: OS#2672
Change-Id: If0659a878deb383ed0300217e2c41c8c79b2b6a5
On MT call, there is a bug in CC conn use which leads to an early free and
use-after-free.
Add msc_vlr_test_call to show both MO and MT call legs separately and reproduce
the failure. It is visible in a sanitizer build (on debian 9).
A subsequent patch will fix the bug: If0659a878deb383ed0300217e2c41c8c79b2b6a5
Related: OS#2672
Change-Id: I6c3ca0c660388b1e2c82df17ec540c846201b0c7
Neels Hofmeyr
Harald Welte